You've decided to sell your vintage furniture. Now comes the question everyone eventually asks: what's the actual best way to do it? The options range from listing it yourself on Craigslist to dropping it at an estate sale to consigning it with a specialist. Each has real trade-offs, and the right answer depends on what you value most — speed, return, or effort.
Selling It Yourself: High Effort, Variable Returns
Listing on Craigslist, Facebook Marketplace, or eBay gives you full control. You set the price, manage inquiries, coordinate pickup, and keep 100% of what the buyer pays. The downside: most DIY sellers significantly undervalue their pieces, attract lowball offers, and spend far more time on the process than they anticipated. Without deep knowledge of the current market, you're likely leaving money on the table — and spending hours doing it.
For common, lower-value pieces, this is fine. For anything with genuine designer attribution or significant age, it's worth considering other options.
Estate Sales: Fast but Wholesale
Estate sale companies are useful when you need to clear an entire home quickly. They'll come in, price everything, and run a multi-day sale. The convenience is real. The trade-off is that estate sale pricing trends wholesale — pieces move fast precisely because they're priced below retail. For exceptional pieces, an estate sale is rarely the highest-return option.
Auction Houses: Hit or Miss
Regional auction houses can do well with the right piece in front of the right bidders. High-end houses like Wright Auction or Rago have deep collector audiences for serious MCM pieces. For mid-range pieces, however, auction fees, buyer's premiums, and the unpredictability of any given sale day can make auctions a gamble. You might get above market — or well below it.
Specialty Platforms (Chairish, 1stDibs): Good Returns, Significant Work
Platforms built specifically for vintage and designer furniture attract buyers who know what they're looking at. The potential returns are meaningfully higher than general marketplaces. The trade-off: you need strong photos, accurate descriptions, responsive communication, and the patience to wait for the right buyer. For sellers who treat it like a job, these platforms perform well. For everyone else, the time investment can feel like a second career.
Consignment: The Middle Path That Often Wins
Consignment sits at an interesting intersection: you get the expertise and platform reach of a specialist without having to become one yourself. A good consignment partner will accurately attribute your piece, photograph it well, price it correctly, and handle buyer communication — all in exchange for a percentage of the sale. For quality mid-century pieces specifically, this arrangement often yields the best net return of any option, because the expertise in pricing and presentation makes a larger difference than the commission.
The critical variable is choosing the right consignment partner. A generalist shop will treat your Milo Baughman lounge chair the same way they'd treat a 1990s recliner. A mid-century specialist knows the difference and prices accordingly.
The Bottom Line
For common pieces in average condition: DIY or estate sale is fine. For quality designer-attributed MCM furniture with real collector appeal: consignment with a specialist almost always wins on net return, especially when you factor in time saved. The commission pays for itself.
Ready to Sell Your Mid-Century Furniture?
Mod City Madness specializes in mid-century modern consignment. We handle photography, listing, and selling across multiple platforms — you just drop it off.
Get in TouchWhat We Buy
At Mod City Mad, we actively purchase the brands and styles that command the best prices today. We specialize in Broyhill Brasilia, Lane Staccato, Danish Modern, sculptural mid-century modern, and Vladimir Kagan style pieces.